Monticello Resorts

Anchor Bay Resort
anchorbayresort.net
2371 N. Untalulti Dr.
Monticello
574.583.367

Andrew’s Lakeside Resort
4925 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-7222

Arbor Lights
arborlightsresort.com
5192 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3437

Bay Point Resort
baypointemonticello.com
4849 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-9226

Bay Side Resort
baysideresortlodging.com
5088 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, In 47960
574.583.3511

Big Timber Lodge
2715 Airport Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3340

Blue Door Cottages
bluedoorcottages.com
5312 N. West Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
877-889-BLUE (2583)
219-253-BLUE (2583)

Clearview Resort
5014 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3624

Countree Aire Resort
countreeaire.com
2875 N West Shafer Dr.
Monticello
574-583-0333

Gordon Pipers Resort
4980 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-8638

Hartigshideaway
hartigshideaway.com
5142 Indiana Beach Dr. 
Monticello, IN
hartigshideaway@sugardog.com 
574-583-3896

Indiana Beach Inc.
5224 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-4141

Lakeside Resort
4251 E. Lake Road 41E
Monticello, IN
574-583-3291

Lighthouse Lodge
thelighthouselodge.com
4866 N. Boxman Place
Monticello
574-583-9142
708-738-2588 cell

Madonna Resort
4957 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-8162

Neon Bay Resort
(formerly Big Chief Lodge)
neonbayresort.com
5014 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello
574-583-6366

Outrigger Resort
RR 1
Monticello, IN
574-583-4451

Pirates Cove Resort (Calla-Crick Inc.)
piratescoveind.com
4770 East Harbor Court
Monticello, IN 47960
574.583.3328

Riviera Complex
rivieracomplex.net
5057 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3366

Shafer Shores Resort
4599 N. West Shafer Dr.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3488

Shafer Shores Too
shafershorestoo.com
4587 & 4585 N. West Shafer Dr.
Monticello
shafershorestoo@yahoo.com
219.838.1577

Silver Shore Resort
5212 E. Wenz Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3531

Spears Beach Vue Resorts
210 N. Illinois St.
Monticello, IN
574-583-8918

Summer Haven Resort
208 Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3629

Vacation Rentals
4383 E. Jennings Loop
Monticello, IN
574-870-0645

Victorian Bay Resorts
5116 E. Indiana Beach Rd.
Monticello, IN
574-583-3433

Western Horizon-DBA White Oaks On The Lake
9111 Key Dr.
Monticello, IN
574-965-4661